Caprese Sandwich with Margherita Pepperoni

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Jump to Recipe

Caprese Pepperoni Sandwich

My grandfather was often referred to as a piece of bread in Italian,  pezzo di pane.

If someone is a piece of bread, it means they are like the salt of the earth, someone you treasure for all the right reasons. I’m not sure how it came to be, but there is probably a tie in with the Italian Catholic faith and what bread means. Or, maybe because bread is so comforting, that it found its way in describing a person that people feel good around.

I recently visited a good friend in the Niagara Falls area that I would not hesitate to call  a piece of bread. Paula was there at the worst time of my life and it was difficult to leave the friendship behind and move to Nashville. She has since relocated back to her home town and we finally visited her. It’s the kind of friendship that just picks right back up, where there is an understanding of souls, and anything and everything can be talked about amongst a level of respect that families don’t often offer. Families tread into deep waters saying too much, expecting too much. Good friends know when to quit, know how to accept differences, because they don’t define each other through each other.

Paula introduced me to the food of Niagara Falls years ago in California because she would come back from a visit loaded down with bread from Di Camillo’s Bakery and Margherita pepperoni from the Latina Marketplace, an Italian grocery store in her neighborhood. If I was lucky, she’d share a little.

On our way home, we stopped at De Camillo’s and Latina’s to bring food back.  I’m not sure what their secret is (Paula says it’s the water), but the bread is different, better than some of our very good bakeries here. Italian bread is not french bread. It has a different flavor.

Pepperoni Or Hard Salami Sandwich? Why Not?

A really good pepperoni curls when you bake it or fry it because it comes in its natural casing. As it curls, it releases some of the fat, but stays in the little circle, making a better pizza. All I can say is that I have never been wild about pepperoni until now. People don’t put pepperoni on sandwiches very often, because it’s a pizza thing, but this has now become a favorite snack or lunch. You only need a little bit because the flavor is so good, making the meat fat content fairly low.

We came home to more tomatoes in our garden, and decided quickly to make caprese sandwiches adding in some fried pepperoni.

As simple as this is, a recipe isn’t really needed.

While I like an Italian sub as much as anyone, it’s usually too much for me, and not something I eat very often. Italian food does not have to be heavy. It’s often that way, due to the American cultural influences. My hope is for you to enjoy tasting food in a more pleasant way and for your next party, I found a site showing some unique and fun ways to enjoy pepperoni.

On another day because all the pepperoni was gone, we made sandwiches using a good black peppered Italian salami. It doesn’t give the same flavor as pepperoni, but it’s a good substitute.

Print Recipe
5 from 2 votes

Margherita Pepperoni Caprese Sandwich

It's quality ingredients that make this sandwich special, fresh mozzarella, Margherita pepperoni, garden homegrown tomatoes and fresh basil on an Italian roll.
Servings: 2


  • Margherita pepperoni enough slices to cover the roll
  • 2 Italian rolls
  • six slices fresh mozzarella cheese or enough for two rolls
  • olive oil
  • 1 fresh tomato
  • few leaves basil
  • salt pepper


  • Slice pepperoni medium thickness and fry in frying pan until it's charred around the rim and shrinks to a cup. Pat grease with paper towel.
  • Toast rolls.
  • On bottom roll place mozzarella cheese, drizzle some olive oil, salt and pepper, add tomato, add a little more olive oil and salt, and top with pepperoni.

Please follow me on instagram. If you make this recipe,  please tag me #spinachtiger.

If you love this recipe, please give it five stars. It means a lot. xoxo

Similar Posts


  1. This food looks really tasty, its amazing how much can be done with fresh bread and fresh ingredients. Running my own eatery called Bistro Stasha I also strive for the same fresh food as seen here. Everyone loves quality like seen above, It’s nice to see more and more places delivering.

  2. Yummy!! I think I saw my husband drool as he was thinking of that tasty bread and fresh mozzarella and garden tomato! You are a culinary artist! Thanks for sharing! And yes, friends like your Paula are gems! Peace and blessings… Kiki

  3. My favorite things to eat all year long are as sandwiches. Every season, all year long. Sandwiches are comforting, easy and just the most simple, yet sophisticated edible I can think of. Your Caprese sandwich is lovely.

  4. Oh yes, Italian bread is different than French bread and dare I say … better?!!

    Wonderful to have friends that you can pick up with at any time as if there was no time lapse!!

  5. I love the idea of a caprese sandwich! Looks amazing. It’s so true that friends are the people you choose to be with and family is not necessarily that way… I love friendships like that we’re you just pickup even after not seeing each other for years. It’s the best kind!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating